City ZOC effect inconsistent (information leak)
"- An enemy city counts as an enemy occupied tile if there are any units inside the city, but not if the city is empty. (This is the same rule as for any other tile.)"
I'm not sure how it behaves at the moment, but that text is certainly wrong as it contradicts itself:
"ANY units inside" vs "SAME RULE as for any ... tile"
In S2_6 only SOME units generate zoc outside cities.
#1 Updated by Jacob Nevins 6 months ago
- Category changed from Documentation to General
- Target version changed from 2.6.0 to 2.6.0-beta1
I think the actual behaviour on the server is that only UTYF_NOZOC units impose ZoC even when in a city (so really "the same rule as for any other tile").
However, the client treats any occupied city as imposing ZoC (for goto etc).
There's a knowledge / information leak problem here. You can currently tell if a city only contains no-ZoC units by trying to walk past it (by hand rather than with goto) -- verified experimentally. You shouldn't be able to tell that.
I think this is a new problem in 2.6, since gna bug #21507 added UTYF_NOZOC.
The simplest fix for 2.6 is probably to decree that enemy occupied cities always impose ZoC, regardless of the occupying unit.
(Also, from inspection, I'm not entirely convinced that pathfinding understands the new ZoC rules, but I haven't tested it or looked in detail.)
#3 Updated by Marko Lindqvist 6 months ago
- File 0005-Occupied-enemy-cities-always-impose-ZoC.patch 0005-Occupied-enemy-cities-always-impose-ZoC.patch added
- File 0008-Occupied-enemy-cities-always-impose-ZoC.patch 0008-Occupied-enemy-cities-always-impose-ZoC.patch added
- Status changed from New to Resolved